Cafe 25:35

⭐️⭐️

2025-02-02

We had breakfast. The service was okay. We had to ask for refills. No one checked with us after food was served. The eggs and sausage was good, but the pancakes were flat and chewy. Would have preferred hash browns but only offered home fries which had a seasoning that I didn’t care for. The menu did not have prices listed which I found irritating. The place appeared to be an upscale cafe but was disappointing.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

2025-01-20

Great food at this random cafe in the middle of Old Downtown Buckeye. Getting here is not too easy and parking is sort of tough. The restaurant is very small and gets very crowed really quick. Food is excellent but staff could do a bit of a refresh on customer service skills and be a little friendlier. This restaurant closes early.. and I mean early so you have to come here fairly early during the day before 2PM. If owners are watching this, please open a little later. Maybe close at 4PM? That would be very helpful.

⭐️

2024-12-21

Visited Cafe 25:35, apparently named after some Matthew verse in the Bible (I guess they forgot the part about being kind to strangers). I was greeted by the darker-haired girl in glasses, who I'm pretty sure could give lessons on how to make you feel unwelcome. Her hospitality was so bad, it felt like she was auditioning for 'Grumpy Waitress: The Musical.' She was tucked away in the back corner, muttering seat assignments to herself like she was casting spells. No wonder no one could hear her - maybe if she moved her lips a bit more or, you know, actually walked up to greet people, it would help. Instead, she just shot dirty looks at the poor souls trying to figure out where to sit, like she was practicing for a glare-off competition. The food? Eh, it was okay - if you're into paying premium for mediocrity. But hey, at least the ambiance was unintentionally hilarious. If you're looking for a place where the service is as warm as the Arctic winter and the prices are as inflated as my expectations for kindness, then Cafe 25:35 is your spot. Overall, I'd give this place one star, but that's only because their coffee was somewhat drinkable. Maybe they should rename it to Cafe 25:36; "You have heard that it was said, 'Love your neighbor,' but here, we just give you looks that could kill.